When a big company comes after a hot startup, it’s not a slam dunk decision to sell

Comment
Rumors first surfaced last month that Google was going after cloud security startup Wiz and a $23 billion offer was on the table, the most lucrative offer ever made for a startup. Before the deal eventually died, there would have been a lot of moving parts, and it’s fair to ask: What are the mechanics when a big deal like this is set in motion, and how does a startup decide to sell or not?
We spoke to Jyoti Bansal, who is founder and CEO at Harness, a developer tools startup that has raised approximately $575 million and has made a bunch of small acquisitions along the way. While Bansal doesn’t have direct knowledge of the Google-Wiz negotiation process, he experienced being courted by a large company when Cisco came after his previous startup AppDynamics. Cisco ended up buying the company just a few days before it was set to go public in 2017 for $3.7 billion.
He says there are three factors in play when it comes to deals like this. The first is how serious the offer is and whether it’s concrete or just exploratory. For a private company like Wiz, chances are it’s going to be exploratory at first because there is not a lot of public information available on its financials as there would be with a public company.
Bansal says when he went through the AppDynamics negotiations with Cisco, he had recently filed an S-1 with the SEC and all his financial cards were already on the table. “So for an acquirer, acquiring a private company that’s on the IPO path and a few days from an IPO is essentially no different than acquiring a public company,” he said. “All the information they need is out there, and they don’t have to worry about if they’re missing some information, or the information is not clean, audited or scrutinized.”
Once you determine how serious the company is, you have to explore whether this would be a good match. “The second factor in any kind of courtship that happens is what’s the reason for the combined company? Is that interesting? Is that exciting?” You also have to take into consideration what happens to your employees and your products: Will some employees lose their jobs? Will products be deprecated or canceled?
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, you have to scrutinize the economics of the deal to see whether they make sense and whether they are a good value for shareholders. From Wiz’s perspective, it was a huge offer (assuming the rumored amount was accurate) that was 46 times its current ARR and 23 times its projected 2025 ARR. Yet Wiz thought it would be better off remaining a private company.
In Bansal’s case, when Cisco came a courtin’, he was in the middle of his company’s IPO road show. It was days before the company was going public, but even with the information out there for Cisco to analyze, there were discussions, and it wasn’t easy for Bansal to give up his baby, even if the price eventually was right.
The two companies knew that there was a strict deadline in front of them. Once the IPO happened, that would be that. The negotiations ended up involving three offers, and when it was over, Cisco got its company. “Ultimately, it comes down to what’s best for all the shareholders in terms of risk and reward. It’s all about what’s the risk of being independent versus the reward of selling,” Bansal said.
The first offer was in line with IPO value and was an easy no. The second one was better, but after discussing it with the board, Bansal said no again. “Then they came back with a third offer, and in the third offer, it made sense from a risk versus reward for our shareholders to sell the company.” And sell they did in the range 2.5 to 3 times the IPO valuation.
It’s easy to think that with billions of dollars at stake, it would be an easy decision to sell, but it really wasn’t. “It was not an easy decision from our side. It sounds like [$3.7 billion] is a very easy decision.” But he says you have to poll your investors, your fellow executives, your board members — and they all have different interests, and you are trying to come to the right decision for everyone involved.
Wiz thought it was better staying independent. For AppDynamics, with the pressure of the IPO deadline looming and a good offer on the table, the company finally went for it. “So for us to independently grow into that valuation of two and a half, three times more than our IPO valuation would have taken us at least three years of good execution to grow into it,” he said. “And there were a lot of unknowns, a lot of risk for the company like what happens in the next three years.”
But that doesn’t mean he doesn’t have some regrets in spite of making more than 300 of his employees millionaires with the transaction and personal wealth for himself. When he looks back at the timing of the announcement, he realizes that it’s entirely possible he could have made that much money and more.
“I always wonder what AppDynamics could have become if we had gone through with the IPO. There are a lot of unknowns, and hindsight is 20/20, but if you look back, we sold the company in 2017, the few years after that sale, after 2017, were some of the best boom years in the tech industry, especially for B2B SaaS,” he said. In the end, he might have made more, but instead he started Harness, and he’s happy building a second company.
It’s important to note that Wiz’s offer remains mired in rumor, so it may or may not be that much money. But if it was, the founders could also have regrets if Wiz doesn’t grow into the value it could have had if it had taken the big money money and run.
Every weekday and Sunday, you can get the best of TechCrunch’s coverage.
Startups are the core of TechCrunch, so get our best coverage delivered weekly.
The latest Fintech news and analysis, delivered every Tuesday.
TechCrunch Mobility is your destination for transportation news and insight.
By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice.
Chief Product Officer Craig Saldanha says AI is already transforming the Yelp experience.
Featured Article
Any goal that puts cultivated meat in big box grocery stores or on fast food menus in the 2020s is “unrealistic,” according to experts.
Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway cut its Apple holding by around half, to $84.2 billion, according to an SEC filing. While Apple remains the firm’s largest stock holding by far, Buffett…
A fireside chat between Jensen Huang and Mark Zuckerberg at SIGGRAPH 2024 took some unexpected turns. What started as a conversation about the capabilities of Nvidia GPUs and Zuckerberg’s vision…
We spoke to Harness CEO and founder Jyoti Bansal about his previous company, which Cisco bought for $3.7 billion in 2017.
Dojo is Tesla’s custom-built supercomputer that’s designed to train its “Full Self-Driving” neural networks.
Featured Article
Trade My Spin has pieced together a logistics network capable of offering same or next day delivery in most major cities in the continental U.S.
Featured Article
Sanjiva Weerawarana co-founded WSO2 in 2005, recently selling it for more than $600M. He sometimes drives for Uber, too.
Investors are assisting startup founders earlier than ever in an effort to help them bridge the first climate tech valley of death.
While both the DSA and DMA aim to achieve distinct things, they are best understood as a joint response to Big Tech’s market power.
Featured Article
A scathing rebuke by the U.K. data protection watchdog reveals what led to the compromise of tens of millions of U.K. voters’ information.
Self-driving technology company Aurora Innovation was hoping to raise hundreds of millions in additional capital as it races toward a driverless commercial launch by the end of 2024. The company, which…
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission and the Justice Department are suing TikTok and ByteDance, TikTok’s parent company, with violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA). The law requires digital…
Welcome to Startups Weekly — your weekly recap of everything you can’t miss from the world of startups.  This week we are looking at acquisitions of small startups, two new…
In a big move, Character.AI co-founder and CEO Noam Shazeer is returning to Google after leaving the company in October 2021 to found the a16z-backed chatbot startup. In his previous…
The startup developed a two-material system that helps homes self-regulate their internal humidity.
When the developers replied to the July 19 email, Yelp sent a deck of pricing tiers with base pricing starting from $229 per month for a limit of 1,000 API…
Featured Article
The cloud infrastructure market has put the doldrums of 2023 firmly behind it with another big quarter. Revenue continues to grow at a brisk pace, fueled by interest in AI. Synergy Research reports revenue totaled $79 billion for the quarter, up $14.1 billion or 22% from last year. This marked…
The pharma giant won’t say how many patients were affected by its February data breach. A count by TechCrunch confirms that over a million people are affected.
Payments infrastructure firm Infibeam Avenues has acquired a majority 54% stake in Rediff.com for up to $3 million, a dramatic twist of fate for the 28-year-old business that was the…
The ruling confirmed an earlier decision in April from the High Court of Podgorica which rejected a request to extradite the crypto fugitive to the United States.
A day after Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg talked about his newest social media experiment Threads reaching “almost” 200 million users on the company’s Q2 2024 earnings call, the platform has…
TechCrunch Disrupt 2024 will be in San Francisco on October 28–30, and we’re already excited! Disrupt brings innovation for every stage of your startup journey, and we could not bring you this…
Featured Article
The tech layoff wave is still going strong in 2024. Following significant workforce reductions in 2022 and 2023, this year has already seen 60,000 job cuts across 254 companies, according to independent layoffs tracker Layoffs.fyi. Companies like Tesla, Amazon, Google, TikTok, Snap and Microsoft have conducted sizable layoffs in the…
Intel announced it would lay off more than 15% of its staff, or 15,000 employees, in a memo to employees on Thursday. The massive headcount is part of a large…
Following the recent lawsuit filed by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) against music generation startups Udio and Suno, Suno admitted in a court filing on Thursday that it did, in…
In spite of a drop for the quarter, iPhone remained Apple’s most important category by a wide margin.
Molly Alter wears a lot of hats. She’s a mocumentary filmmaker working on a project about an alternate reality where charades is big business. She’s a caesar salad connoisseur and…
Microsoft has a long and tangled history with OpenAI, having invested a reported $13 billion in the ChatGPT maker as part of a long-term partnership. As part of the deal,…
The San Jose-based startup raised $60 million in a round that values it lower than the $500 million valuation it garnered in its most recent round, according to multiple sources.
Powered by WordPress VIP

source
Sponsor:News technical sponsor
Sponsor:News AI sponsor
Sponsor: AI sponsor
Sponsor: AI sponsor